| Platinum | The Patio On Broadway |
| Gold | Three Wishes Bakery |
| Silver | Den Den Cafe Asiana |
| Bronze | Joe Marzilli's Old Canteen |
| Top Pick | Olneyville New York System |
| Top Pick | Red Stripe |
| Top Pick | Sam's New York System Weiners |
| Top Pick | Siena Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Sandwich Hut |
| Top Pick | Xo Cafe |